The Edge · 8 Moves Framework Move 7: Redirect & Counter

➡️ Negotiation Tip: Start With the Worst-Case Scenario- Conflict Resolution Hack

Most conflict drags on because everyone avoids the real issue.

Watch the short version

Most people dance around conflict until it festers into something worse. The counterintuitive move that cuts through the noise: name the worst-case scenario first.

Why We Avoid the Elephant

Conflict persists because everyone knows what could happen, but nobody says it. The employee who’s checked out. The client who won’t commit. The business partner who’s going through the motions. We hint. We hope. We hint some more.

73%

of workplace conflicts escalate because the core issue remains unaddressed

Conflict Resolution Institute, 2023

The underlying fear drives the avoidance. What if they actually say yes to walking away? What if naming the worst outcome makes it real? This backward logic keeps us trapped in unproductive loops where everyone wastes time pretending the obvious isn’t obvious.

◆ Insight
Fear of the worst-case scenario gives it more power than it deserves.

The Clarity Move

Put it on the table directly. “It doesn’t seem like this is working. Should we part ways?” Watch what happens next.

The emotional charge disappears. When the worst outcome gets named explicitly, it loses its grip. No more wondering. No more tiptoeing. The conversation shifts from managing anxiety to solving problems.

"The thing you’re afraid to say is usually the thing that needs to be said."

You get honesty instead of performance. People stop pretending when the pretense becomes pointless. The disengaged employee admits they’re looking elsewhere. The uncommitted client reveals their real concerns. The checked-out partner explains what’s actually bothering them.

Traditional Approach
Hint at problems, hope for change, frustration builds
Worst-Case First
Name the outcome, create clarity, focus on solutions

Beyond Ultimatums

This isn’t about issuing threats. It’s about creating space for truth. When you remove the fear of the worst outcome, you often discover it’s not what either party actually wants.

→ Tactic
Frame it as a question, not a demand. “Should we explore other options?” vs. “Do this or else.”

The magic happens in that pause after you name it. Most people realize they’d rather fix the problem than face the alternative. But some will surprise you and say yes, they do want out. Both responses give you something valuable: clarity.

This connects to Move 7 in negotiation — redirecting the conversation away from positions and toward underlying interests. Sometimes the redirect starts with acknowledging the position nobody wants to defend.

Worst Case

Ready to identify your natural negotiation patterns and potential blind spots?

Take the Free Style Assessment →

Want to go deeper?

Find out how you negotiate — and where you're leaving money behind.

Take the Free Assessment →
Share
LinkedInFacebookText